What can I say about Stephen King that hasn't already been said a thousand times before? Probably not much. This isn't even a new novel from King, and I am way behind the times in only just now reading it.
However, as I always promise to let my students know what I think of the books I read, here I go:
First of all, I strongly believe that King's strength as a writer lies in the fantastic -- that line between mundane reality and the sublime paranormal. He made his name in that genre, and that fame is definitely well-deserved.
This novel focuses purely on the world as it is, although there are interesting psychological elements to the story. I normally love psychological thrillers and murder mysteries (even when the whodunnit is revealed early on), but this story felt merely adequate.
This is a strong entry into the genre of detective fiction, but it would never stand out without the name of Stephen King attached to it. In fact, the work itself seems keenly aware of the fact that it is using the conventions of detective fiction: the beautiful sidekick, the insouciant angle of one's hat, the jaded older man, and the vigilantism of those who believe they are more effective than the law.
*Disclosure: Purchases made through links on this review may result in compensation for The Modern Minerva. All opinions expressed here are based on my personal experience. The Modern Minerva is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
To be perfectly frank, I mostly didn't love this novel because I mostly don't love old school detective fiction. I love a good crime drama, police procedural, or murder mystery, but I just can't really get into this kind of story. I had hoped that the psychological element here would be enough to grab me, but I'm afraid there are better psychological thrillers out there. As a blend of detective fiction, psychological thriller, and murder mystery, King has crafted something interesting. But as a story taken on its own merits, I just can't love it.
I still recommend reading it if detective fiction is your thing. The language is, for the most part, clear and direct, the plot is easy to follow and straightforward, and the characters are distinct and dynamic. I'm glad I read it, but I just won't be running out to buy any of the sequels.
Have you read Mr. Mercedes? If so, what did you think? Did I miss something that makes this a work of genius? Let me know in the comments below.